Walk through Combinatorics, Fall 2016
Highly non-parallel roads
When:Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays 9:30
Where:Wean Hall 8201
If you ever stumbled upon a mathematical object that is finite and is fun to play with, you must have wandered into the land of combinatorics (also known as discrete mathematics). You might have walked there through one of the many well-trodden roads from logic and computer science, or were yanked through some of the recently-discovered wormholes from number theory or topology. Even if you have not been there, you still might want a guide.
In this course we will explore this land, and learn of paths that connect its different parts. We will focus on three areas:
- Ramsey theory, where we learn how to find order in the utter chaos. Here the main results are the pigeonhole principle, Ramsey's theorem, theorems of van der Waerden and Hales–Jewett. Much of the time will be devoted to their applications.
- Enumerative combinatorics, where we learn how to count not only trees, and forests, but also walks, and cycles. Here we encounter clever bijections, Möbius inversion formula, generating functions, Cauchy's theorem as a tool in asymptotic analysis, as well as a multitude of combinatorial objects to count.
- Probabilistic method, where we learn how use the power of randomness to conjure mathematical objects that are both simple and exotic. Our main helpers will be linearity of expectations, second moment method, alteration tricks, Lovász local lemma, and concentration inequalities. We will also see and use the famed Szemerédi regularity lemma.
Due to the variety of topics, there is no single book that covers everything. Some good written resources covering parts of the course are
- Ramsey theory by Ronald Graham, Bruce Rothschild, and Joel Spencer [library]
- Enumerative combinatorics, volume I by Richard Stanley [library]
- Concrete mathematics by Ronald Graham, Donald Knuth, and Oren Patashnik [library]
- Generatingfunctionology by Herbert Wilf [library] [online]
- Analytic combinatorics by Philippe Flajolet, and Robert Sedgewick [library] [online]
- Probabilistic method by Noga Alon, and Joel Spencer [library]
- Probability Theory and Combinatorial Optimization by Michael Steele for Azuma trickery [video]
- Graph theory by Reinhard Diestel [library] [online]
Links to additional resources will be posted as the course progresses.
More fun can be had at my office hours on Wednesdays 2:30–3:30pm and Thursdays 10:30–11:30am in Wean 6202. I am also available by appointment.
Mastery of combinatorics requires practice. Hence, there will be regular homeworks. For your own good, you are strongly encouraged to do as much homework as possible individually. Collaboration and use of external sources are permitted, but must be fully acknowledged and cited. All the writing must be done individually. Failure to do so will be treated as cheating. Collaboration may involve only discussion; all the writing must be done individually. The homeworks will be returned one week after they are due.
Students are expected to fully participate in the class. Discussions during the lectures are encouraged.
The homework will count for 50% of the grade. During the semester there will be two tests (on October 26, and December 7). Each test will count for 25% of the grade. There will be no final exam.
Homework must be submitted in LaTeX via e-mail. I want both the LaTeX file and the PDF that is produced from it. The filenames must be of the form lastname_discr_homeworknumber.tex and lastname_discr_homeworknumber.pdf respectively. Pictures do not have to be typeset; a legible photograph of a hand-drawn picture is acceptable.
The homework must be submitted by 9:30am of the day it is due. For each minute that it is late, the grade will be reduced by 10%.
There will be opportunities for extra credit. Unusually insightful solutions, and other achievements will be appropriately rewarded.
- August 29: Introduction. Dirichlet's approximation theorem. Dirichlet's theorem is mostly sharp.
- August 31: Erdős–Szekeres on monotone sequences. Ramsey's theorem. Bounds on the middle binomial coefficient. Stirling's formula (statement). Homework #1
- September 2: Schur's theorem. Lower bounds on Ramsey numbers. About bounds on the Ramsey function, and probabilistic arguments. Hypergraphs. Ramsey's theorem for hypergraphs.
- September 5: Labor Day
- September 7: Ramsey's theorem for hypergraphs (vertex and edge versions). Erdős–Szekeres on points in convex position.
- September 9: Stepping-up lemma. Infinite Ramsey theorem. Compactness principle (statement). Infinite Ramsey theorem implies finite Ramsey theorem. Notes on the compactness principle. Homework #2
- September 12: Proof of compactness principle. van der Waerden's theorem (part I).
- September 14: van der Waerden's theorem (part II).
- September 16: van der Waerden's theorem (part III). Statement of Hales–Jewett theorem. Tic-tac-toe. Gallai's theorem.
- September 19: Cubes in sets of positive density. Szemerédi's proof of Roth's theorem (part I).
- September 21: Szemerédi's proof of Roth's theorem (part II). Behrend's construction (part I). Homework #3
- September 23: Behrend's construction (part II). Binomial coefficients. Binomial theorem. Changemaking in Fictionland.
- September 26: Monetary reform in Fictionland. Partial fraction decomposition. Generating functions and formal power series. Weak compositions.
- September 28: Solving linear recurrence relations via generating functions. Vandermonde's convolution. Alternating permutations. Review of complex analysis (part I): differentiability.
- September 30: Review of complex analysis (part II): counter integration and Cauchy's theorem.
- October 3: Review of complex analysis (part III): Taylor's theorem. Asymptotics for alternating permutations. Sharper asymptotics for alternating permutations.
- October 5: Catalan numbers. Dyck paths. Bijection for Catalan numbers (existence part). Homework #4
- October 7: Bijection for Catalan numbers (uniqueness part). Fibonacci without rabbits.
- October 10: Pringsheim's theorem. Balanced trees.
- October 12: Domino tilings at large (part I).
- October 14: Domino tilings at large (part II). Probability spaces. Random variables. LYM inequality. Sum-free subsets.
- October 17: Dominating sets. Independent sets. Graphs with large girth and large chromatic number.
- October 19: Property B. Homework #5
- October 21: Mid-semester break
- October 24: Second moment method. Guest lecture by Tom Bohman
- October 26: Test
- October 28: No class
- October 31: Distinct sums. Chernoff's inequality. Concentration of binomial random variables. Martingales.
- November 2: Edge-exposure martingales. Vertex-exposure martingales. General exposure martingales. Lipschitz functions. Azuma's inequality. Concentration of the chromatic number. Notes on exposure martingales. Homework #6
- November 4: No class
- November 7: Mean of chromatic number (part I). Notes on the chromatic number of a random graph.
- November 9: Mean of chromatic number (part II). Isoperimetric problem.
- November 11: Two-source extractors and Ramsey graphs (diversion). Motivation for the local lemma. Local lemma. Property B in sparse hypergraphs.
- November 14: Multicolored translates. Latin transversals.
- November 16 (Double-length class): Szemerédi's regularity lemma. Triangle counting lemma. Triangle removal lemma. Notes on the regularity lemma Homework #7
- November 18: Another proof of Roth's theorem. Basic idea of additive combinatorics.
- November 21: Sum product estimates over R. Szemerédi–Trotter theorem.
- November 28: Crossing lemma. Triangle inequalities. Notes on sumset inequalities.
- November 30 (Double-length class): Sumset inequalities. Sum-product theorem in Fp. Additive energy. Balog–Szemerédi–Gowers theorem (part I). Homework #8
- December 2: Balog–Szemerédi–Gowers theorem (part II). Szemerédi–Trotter in Fp (part I).
- December 5: Szemerédi–Trotter in Fp (part II).
- December 7: Test
- December 9: Szemerédi–Trotter in Fp (part III). Some applications of the sum-product theorem (no proofs).